My Brother-in-Law Mocked Me Constantly — I Sabotaged a Job He Wanted, and He Found Another Career
I did not expect the truth to hit me standing in my mother-in-law's back garden, holding a paper plate of potato salad and a too-sweet drink. Dylan was talking to a cousin I barely knew. The sun was loud. Kids tore through the grass with water guns. Evan argued with the grill behind me. It looked like any harmless family cookout.
Source: UGC
Then Dylan laughed and said, "There was this job I almost got once. Management trainee at a big logistics company. Closest I ever came to getting out of those dead-end years. Sometimes I still wonder where I'd be if I'd landed that one."
My throat tightened.
He had no idea. Not a clue. His face was relaxed, his tone ordinary, as if talking about missing a bus. To him, it was just an interesting footnote in his life. To me, it was a memory that sat in my chest like a stone.
Because I knew exactly why he never got that job.
I was the reference who told the recruiter what he was like to work with. I did not lie. I did not exaggerate. I only described him the way he had treated me back then. Blunt. Dismissive. Convinced he was the most intelligent man in any room. And those words had consequences.
Source: UGC
Standing there in the sun, watching Dylan joke about the road not taken, I wondered whether I had ruined something or been part of something far quieter and stranger. Something like fate. Or timing. Or the clumsy collisions that shape people without them ever knowing.
And I wondered, for the first time in years, whether I should tell him.
My name is Maya. I am in my early thirties, and when I married my husband, Evan, I also inherited his family. Most of them welcomed me easily, with hugs, over-shared recipes, and warm fussing about how good it was to have another woman in the mix. But not Dylan.
Dylan was Evan's older brother. Taller, louder, sharper around the edges. The kind of man who imagined he was joking when he was actually being cruel. When he first met me, he shook my hand with a smirk, as if my very presence amused him in the wrong way.
Source: UGC
It did not get better quickly. Our first year as in-laws had a few cuts. Dry little digs. Comments disguised as humour. Correcting my pronunciation, interrupting my stories, and rolling his eyes when I spoke to Evan about anything mildly serious.
It felt like I was trespassing. Like my marriage was some group project someone had assigned Dylan and hadn't approved. He never declared open war. He dripped disrespect into every interaction; a slow erosion.
Evan saw some of it. Not all. He tried to talk to Dylan once, and it ended with Dylan calling him dramatic and telling him I needed a thicker skin. I did not want to fracture the family further, so I swallowed most of the hurt and kept things polite.
Back then, Dylan worked long hours in a job he hated. He complained nonstop about his supervisors, customers, schedules, and salary. I still sympathised. I never saw him as malicious. Just immature. Just stuck.
Source: UGC
So when I learned, by coincidence, that he had applied for a management trainee role at a major logistics company, I remember thinking it might actually be good for him. A chance to grow up. A chance to be surrounded by people who might hold him accountable. An opportunity for him to step out of the bitterness he wrapped himself in like a blanket.
I did not know then what my role in that story would become.
During that first rough year, Dylan applied for the trainee position. It was competitive. Structured. Built for people who could take feedback and collaborate without posturing. The sort of environment Dylan insisted he deserved, though his behaviour told another story.
Two weeks after he mentioned it at a family lunch, my phone buzzed. It was Laura, a former coworker of mine and a casual friend I had not spoken to in months.
Source: UGC
"Hey, Maya," she said. "Random question. Do you know a Dylan Carson? Applied here. Your last name popped up in a system note, so I thought I'd check."
I remember freezing for a second. "He's my brother-in-law," I said finally.
"Oh perfect," she replied. "What's he like to work with?"
And that was the moment, the crossroads I did not recognise until much later.
I did not rant. I did not unleash my feelings. I did not even consciously think about revenge. I just told Laura what I had seen of my brother-in-law, because I assumed honesty was what she wanted.
"He can be blunt," I said carefully. "Sometimes to the point of rudeness. He struggles to take feedback unless it aligns with his own opinions. He often assumes he's the most competent person in the room."
Laura hummed. "That helps. Thank you."
Source: UGC
When we hung up, I felt uneasy. Not guilty, exactly. Just unsettled. But I reminded myself I had not lied. I had not set out to harm Dylan. I only described the version of him that he consistently showed me.
He did not get the job.
He never mentioned the reference check or asked if I knew why. Life rolled on. Dylan stayed at his old job, kept complaining, and kept insisting that management felt threatened by him. But something else shifted, too.
He cooled off. Little by little, like a kettle that had been switched off but took its time losing heat. He stopped with the jabs. He stopped rolling his eyes as much. Once, he even asked for my advice about a birthday gift for Evan.
It was not friendship. Not yet. But it was a doorway. A subtle softening. The start of something that felt less like a battlefield and more like a cautious truce.
Source: UGC
By the time we hit year five of my marriage, Dylan had become tolerable. Then decent; then surprisingly helpful. He started picking up the nephews when Evan's sister had work commitments.
He started apologising when he realised he had interrupted someone. He began reading books about workplace communication and emotional intelligence. He became a version of himself I had never expected.
And I assumed, naïvely, that the past was behind us.
Until that cookout.
Until he told that story with easy regret, unaware that my quiet honesty years earlier had nudged his life in a different direction.
After he made that comment at the cookout, I found myself replaying the entire timeline like a film. Dylan, standing under a string of garden lights, flipping sausages like he owned the grill. Laughing. Balanced. More grounded. Nothing like the defensive, abrasive man I had known at the start.
He kept talking to his cousin, not knowing I was listening.
Source: UGC
"That job would've changed everything," he said. "But I guess I wasn't meant for it. They said I wasn't the right fit. Probably dodged a bullet. Would've tried to lead before I even learned to follow back then."
I almost choked on my drink.
He said it with humility. With perspective. With a sense of self-awareness I could not have imagined in him years ago. And that was the moment the real twist settled in.
Dylan had grown because he failed.
If he had gotten that management trainee role, he would have stepped into a world that demanded emotional maturity he did not yet have. A world that would have crushed him, embarrassed him, or hardened him further. A world that might have driven him deeper into resentment instead of nudging him toward change.
But he did not get it. He stayed in the job he hated, yes, but something in him softened over those years. Those humbling years. Those years that forced him to look at himself and at the patterns that kept him stuck.
Source: UGC
Eventually, he left logistics behind and chose a hands-on, community-focused path that favoured his directness. He grew more patient. More observant. More reflective.
He grew into someone I respected.
And the kicker, the part that twisted like a quiet knife, was that he still wondered what might have happened if he had landed that role.
He had no idea that my words had helped close that door.
That night, after the cookout, I sat on the edge of my bed thinking about the situation more honestly than I ever had before.
I did not sabotage Dylan on purpose. But I had shaped something that mattered, even if I had no intention of doing so. And now, years later, I had to decide whether to say something.
I pictured the conversation: me telling him that I had been the reference. That I had spoken plainly. That my words might have tipped the scales. I pictured the confusion on his face, then the anger, then the hurt. And I pictured the relationship we had built since. The small trust we had earned. The quiet respect we both contributed to now.
Source: UGC
What purpose would the confession serve?
Would it heal anything? No.
Would it teach him something he had not already learned through his own growth? No.
Would it make me feel better? Not really. The guilt was old and softened, more of a memory than a wound.
Telling him would be honesty, yes. But it would also be a grenade, a needless one.
So I chose not to tell him.
I chose instead to honour the relationship we had now, not the one we had before. Back then, Dylan would not have survived that management environment. He would have clashed with every supervisor. He would have interpreted every critique as an attack. He needed the years that came after, the years that sanded down the roughest parts of him.
Sometimes failure is an unexpected teacher. Sometimes it is the only teacher someone will actually listen to.
And Dylan listened. Eventually, he changed. He became better, happier, and able to laugh at himself and not mock others first.
Source: UGC
So I decided my responsibility was not to rip open an old story, but to take responsibility for the present. To be steady. To be respectful. To move forward with the version of Dylan who exists now.
Not the one who once made me feel like an intruder.
I am not proud of the role I played, but I accept it. Some past mistakes do not need any revival. Some dissolve quietly into the life that grows afterwards.
What happened with Dylan taught me something about growth that I had never understood before. I always believed progress came from clarity, from honesty, from talking things through. But sometimes, strangely, people grow most in the spaces where they never learn the complete story.
If I had told Dylan the truth that year, he would have blamed me instead of looking inward. He would have insisted the recruiters were unfair. He would have doubled down on the narrative that everyone else was the problem.
Source: UGC
Instead, the rejection came from an invisible place. A place my brother-in-law could not argue with or deflect. It forced him to consider why others might not see him the way he saw himself. It made him ask questions he had avoided for years. It nudged him toward accountability.
And it led him, slowly and imperfectly, to a version of himself that treats people with more care than he ever treated me in the beginning.
Our relationship today is simple. Respectful. Balanced. Dylan brings Evan thoughtful gifts. He asks my opinion without sounding condescending. He helps out at family gatherings in ways he never used to. He apologises when he realises he has interrupted someone. He is not perfect; nobody is. But he is better. And I can see it clearly.
Sometimes the past contains moments we are not proud of. Moments when fear, irritation, or pain shaped our decisions. Moments when we acted before we understood ourselves.
But the real question, the one I hold onto now, is this:
Am I helping the relationships in my life grow, or am I feeding the versions of people they used to be?
Because the truth is simple, we all have histories that could break something if spoken too late. And we all have choices about what kind of future we want to build in their place.
This story is inspired by the real experiences of our readers. We believe that every story carries a lesson that can bring light to others. To protect everyone's privacy, our editors may change names, locations, and certain details while keeping the heart of the story true. Images are for illustration only. If you'd like to share your own experience, please contact us via email.
Source: YEN.com.gh
